Using The Tiller To Taxi The Boeing 737

captain-side steering tiller

To taxi an aircraft around the airport the pilot uses either the rudder pedals and/or a steering wheel device called a tiller.  The half-moon shaped tiller is mounted to the sidewall of the flight deck.  The number of tillers in an aircraft is not standard; some aircraft have one tiller while some have two.  The tiller controls the lateral movement of the aircraft’s nose wheel, located below and behind the flight deck.

The rudder pedals when pressed do provide some lateral movement, however, nose wheel steering is no more than 7 degrees.  To enable full lateral movement of the nose wheel  requires using the tiller with some forward thrust (called break-away thrust) from the aircraft’s engines.   

If the aircraft is to be moved backwards (for example from the ramp), then a push-back truck and ground controller is required.  The controller will connect a bar from the push-back truck to the main coupling of the nose wheel to lock the nose wheel in the forward position.  Once this is done, the push-back truck will lift the nose wheel enabling the aircraft to be reversed backwards.  A push-back truck can also be used to pull the aircraft forwards.

The ground controller will be in communication with the pilot and will instruct the pilot when it is safe to release the parking brake or start the engines (it is the responsibility of the ground controller, amongst other things, to check that the doors are closed and that personnel are clear of the aircraft).  Prior to the aircraft being moved, the pilot will speak with Air Traffic Control to obtain starting and push-back approval.

After ATC has given clearance, the pilot will:

  1. Check and cross check the taxi route instructions issued by ATC.

  2. Release the parking brake by pressing the upper section of the toe brakes.

  3. Apply forward thrust by advancing both thrust levers to around 32%.  The actual percentage N1 depends on the weight of the aircraft.  The forward thrust should not exceed 40%N1.

  4. Use the tiller to maneuver the aircraft.

  5. To stop the aircraft the thrust levers are brought back to idle, the toe brakes are pressed to stop any forward movement of the aircraft, and the parking brake applied.

Although not recommended, it is possible to aid in the turn by applying appropriate thrust only to one engine.

Important Points:

  • Reverse thrust should not be used to move the aircraft backwards primarily because of the likelihood on ingesting foreign material into the engine.

  • Whenever the aircraft is at a standstill the parking brake should be applied.

Taxi Speeds

Taxi speeds vary.  Generally, in good conditions the maximum permissible speeds are:

  • 10 knots – when doing turns;

  • 30 knots – when traveling in a straight-line along a runway;

  • 50 knots – when back-tracking along a runway; and,

  • If the runway is contaminated (ice, snow, etc) the taxi speeds are reduced to 5 knots.

How To Taxi

The nose wheel is located under and to the rear of the flight deck.  Therefore, to turn onto and follow the taxi lines accurately you must slightly overshoot the line prior to turning.

OEM Tiller

Another article addresses how to convert an OEM tiller and use in ProSim737 -  OEM tiller in ProSim737.

Final Call

With a little practice taxing the aircraft in the flight simulator is straightforward.  Points to consider are turning the nose wheel at the correct time (before crossing the line) and applying the correct amount of thrust based on aircraft weight.

Replacing Bulbs In The Boeing Fire Suppression Panel

Plastic cover removed and internal bulb holder raised to ninety degrees to facilitate bulb change.  Note the lug on the side of the plastic cover.  Boeing 737-800 Fire Suppression Panel

The Fire Suppression Panel (often called the fire handles) resides in the forward part of the center pedestal.  The three fire handles control the fire suppression used to counter any fire that may develop in the engines or the auxiliary power unit (APU). 

When a fire occurs, the fire bell will sound, the fire warning annunciator on the Master Caution System will illuminate, and the handle on the fire panel, that pertains to the particular engine or APU will illuminate.

The three red-coloured handles are illuminated by four 28 volt incandescent bulbs.  These bulbs are very bright and if the bulbs are not extinguished soon after being illuminated the heat they generate can be substantial.  Although the bulbs have an exceptionally long life cycle, regular testing of the fire handles (every flight) and heat can shorten their lifespan, facilitating a bulb replacement.

Clear covers removed showing four 28 Volt bulbs

Replacing Bulbs

To replace one or all of the bulbs the plastic red-coloured cover must be removed from the handle housing.  This is done by carefully depressing the two 1 cm long lugs on each side of the plastic cover and pulling the cover off the housing.  Often the covers can be brittle, especially if the panel is quite old and well used (heat from the bulbs and UV light can cause the plastic cover to become brittle) therefore, care should be taken when depressing the lugs.

When the cover has been removed, the internal bulb holder (which holds four bulbs) can be lifted out to ninety degrees; the bulbs can now be assessed  Be aware that the bulb holder is not easily removable and is designed to swing out only to a ninety degree angle.

Bulb replacement can be by any voltage bulb, however, 28 volt bulbs are the norm.  Using a lower voltage bulb will lower the illumination (and potential heat) and may make it easier to wire in a simulator environment because a dedicated 28 volt power supply is not required.  

Amperage Draw

The amperage draw from 28 volt bulbs, for example during a lights test, is quite high (three handles, four bulbs in each handle is twelve bulbs), especially when combined with other bulbs being illuminated during the test.  This is why a dedicated 28 volt power supply is recommended for the fire handles.

Important Point:

  • The two lugs on the plastic cover can be easily broken, especially if the plastic is slightly brittle.

Final Call

The fire panel used in the 737 Next Generation has changed little from its predecessors; why redesign something that works flawlessly.  Bulb replacement is straightforward as long as care is taken when removing the plastic fire handle cover.  Although 28 volt bulbs are the norm, replacement can be made by lower voltage bulbs if amperage draw or heat is considered a problem.

OEM Trip Reminder Indicator

Trip Reminder Indicator.  A small OEM part that is easily installed to any simulator

The trip reminder indicator (TRI) is a mechanical device installed to the right hand side of the yoke; it’s an airline option.  Basically, the device is three separate digits that can be rotated in any combination, from zero to nine.

The trip indicator is a memory device from which the crew historically used to record the flight number; the pilot uses his thumb to move the three digits to indicate the flight number.  However, over time flight numbers became longer than three digits and the use of the trip indicator, for it’s intended purpose, wanned

I use the trip indicator to dial in the Vref, as it’s often easier to quickly glance at the trip indicator to remind you of the Vref speed rather than look at the PFD or CDU.  Some dial in the Vref + wind speed.

Background

The trip indicator has a very long lineage beginning with the Boeing 707 aircraft.  The device was then ported to the 717, 727 and finally the 737 Classic and Next Generation airframes.

Installation and Backlighting

Because the OEM yoke already has the correctly shaped hole, installation of the trip indicator is straightforward.  If you are using an OEM yoke, you probably will need to carefully remove the blanking cover from the hole.

If a reproduction yoke is used, and the hole is not present, a circular hole will need to be cut from aluminium or plastic to enable the trip indicator to fit snugly into the yoke.  As the three dials are mechanical, there is no requirement to connect the device to an interface card.

Each of the digits on the indicator is backlit by a 5 volt incandescent aircraft bulb. 

The design of the trip indicator is ingenious, in that after the trip indicator has been removed from the yoke (two screws at the front of the yoke secure the indicator), a transparent acrylic slide can be unlocked to slide laterally from behind the three digits (see picture).  The acrylic slide accommodates three 5 volt bulbs, each in its own compartment.

To enable the backlighting to function requires two wires (positive & negative/common) to be connected to the appropriate connection on the rear of the trip indicator, and then to a 5 volt power supply.  The amperage draw from the three bulbs is minimal.  The wiring should be run through the yoke and down the control column so that it comes out at the bottom of the column.

In the aircraft, the backlighting for the trip indicator is connected to the panel light knob located on the center pedestal.  This enables the backlighting on the trip indicator to be turned on and off or dimmed. 

Final Call

The trip reminder indicator is but a small and unobtrusive item, however, it’s often the small things which add considerable immersion and enjoyment when using the simulator.  The trip indicator is also an OEM part that can be very easily installed to a reproduction yoke with minimal experience in fabrication and wiring.

Glossary

OEM - Original Equipment Manufacture.

Throttle Quadrant Rebuild - Flaps Lever Uses String Potentiometer

Flaps lever set to Flaps 30.  The throttle quadrant is from a Boeing 737-500 airframe. The flaps lever arc is the curved piece of aluminium that has has cut-out notches that reflect the various flap positions.  It was beneath this arc that micro-buttons had been installed

There are several ways to enable the flaps lever to register a particular flaps détente when the flaps lever is moved to that position on the flaps arc.

In the earlier conversion, the way I had chosen worked reasonably well.  However, with constant use several inherent problems began to develop.

In this article, we'll examine the new system.  But before going further, I'll briefly explain the method that was previously used.

Overview of Previously Used System

In the earlier conversion, nine (9) micro-buttons were used to register the positions of the flaps lever when it was moved (Flaps UP to Flaps 40). 

The micro-buttons were attached to a half moon shaped piece of fabricated aluminium.  This was mounted beneath the flaps lever arc and attached to the quadrant.  Each micro-button was then connected to an input on a PoKeys 55 interface card.  Each input corresponded to an output.

Calibration was straightforward as each micro-button corresponded to a specific flaps position.

Problems

The system operated reasonably well, however, there were some problems which proved the system to be unreliable.  Namely:

(i)    The vertical and lateral movement of the chain located in the OEM throttle quadrant interferred with the micro-buttons when the trim was engaged; and,

(ii)  The unreliability of the PoKeys 55 interface card to maintain an accurate connection with the micro-buttons.

Movement of OEM Chain

The chain, which is similar in appearance to a heavy duty bicycle chain, connects between two of the main cogs in the throttle quadrant.  When the aircraft is trimmed and the trim wheels rotate, the chain revolves around the cogs.  When the chain rotates there is considerable vertical and some lateral movement of the chain, and it was this movement that caused three micro-buttons to be damaged; the chain rubbed across the bottom section of the micro-buttons, and with time the affected buttons became unresponsive.

First Officer side of a disassembled throttle quadrant  (prior to cleaning and conversion).  The large notched cog is easily seen and it's around this cog that the OEM chain rotates (the chain has been removed)

It took some time to notice this problem, as the chain only rotates when the trim buttons are used, and the micro-buttons affected were primarily those that corresponded to Flaps 5, 10 and 15.  The chain would only rub the three micro-buttons in question when the flap lever was being set to Flaps 5, 10 or 15 and only when the trim was simultaneously engaged.

The cog and chain resides immediately beneath the flaps arc (removed, but is attached to where you can see the four screws in the picture). 

Although there appears to be quite a bit of head- space between the cog and the position where the flaps arc is fitted, the space available is minimal.  Micro-buttons are small, but the structure that the button sits is larger, and it was this structure that was damaged by the movement of the chain (click to enlarge).

An obvious solution to this problem would be to move the chain slightly off center by creating an offset, or to fabricate a protective sleeve to protect the micro-buttons from the movement of the chain.     However, the design became complicated and a simpler solution was sought.

Replacement System

Important criteria when designing a new system is: accuracy, ease of installation, calibration, and maintenance.  Another important criteria is to use the KIS system.  KIS is an acronym used in the Australian military meaning Keep It Simple.

The upgraded system has improved reliability and has made several features used in the earlier system redundant.  These features, such as the QAMP (Quick Access Mounting Plate) in which linear potentiometers were installed, have been removed.

String Potentiometer Replaces Micro-buttons

Single-string potentiometer enables accurate calibration of flaps UP to flaps 40.  The potentiometer is mounted on a customised bracket screwed to the First Officer side of the throttle quadrant superstructure.  The terminal block in the image is part of the stab trim wheel system

A Bourne single-string potentiometer replaced the micro-buttons and previously used linear potentiometers.  The string potentiometer is mounted to a custom-designed bracket on the First Officer side of the throttle quadrant.  The bracket has been fabricated from heavy duty plastic.

A string potentiometer was selected ahead of a linear potentiometer because the former is not limited in throw; all the flap détentes can be registered from flaps UP through to flaps 40.  This is not usually possible with a linear potentiometer because the throw of the potentiometer is not large enough to cater to the full movement of the flaps lever along the arc.

A 'string' is also very sensitive to movement, and any movement of the string (in or out) can be accurately registered.

Another advantage, is that it's not overly important where the potentiometer is mounted, as the string can move across a wide arc, whereas a linear potentiometer requires a straight direction of pull-travel.

Finally, the string potentiometer is a closed unit.  This factor is important as calibration issues often result from dust and grime settling on the potentiometer.  A closed unit for the most part is maintenance free.

The end of the potentiometer string is attached to the lower section of the flaps lever.  As the flaps lever moves along the arc, the string moves in and out of the potentiometer. 

The ProSim737 software has the capability to calibrate the various flap détentes.  Therefore, calibration using FSUIPC is not required.  However, if ProSim737 is not used, then FSUIPC will be needed to calibrate the flap détente positions.

Advantages

Apart from the ease of calibration, increased accuracy, and repeatability that using a string potentiometer brings, two other advantages in using the new system is not having to use a Pokeys 55 card or micro-buttons.

Unreliability of PoKeys 55 Interface Card

The PoKeys card, for whatever reason, wasn't reliable in the previous system.  There were the odd USB disconnects and the card was unable to maintain (with accuracy and repeatability) the position set by the micro-buttons.

I initially replaced the PoKeys card, believing the card to be damaged, however, the replacement card behaved in a similar manner.  Reading the Internet I learned that several other people, who also use ProSim737 as their avionics suite, have had similar problems.

Micro-buttons can and do fail, and replacing one or more micro-buttons beneath the flaps arc is a time-consuming process.  This is because the upper section of the throttle quadrant must be completely dismantled and the trim wheels removed to enable access to the flaps arc.

Registering the Movement of the Flaps Lever in Windows

The movement of the flaps lever, prior to calibration must be registered by the Windows Operating System.  This was done using a Leo Bodnar 086-A Joystick interface card.  This card is mounted in the Throttle Interface Module (TIM).    The joystick card, in addition to the flaps lever, also registers several other button and lever movements on the throttle quadrant.  

Final Call

The rebuild has enabled a more reliable and robust system to be installed that has rectified the shortfalls experienced in the earlier system.  The new system works flawlessly.

  • This article displays links to the majot journal posts concerning the 737 throttle: OEM Throttle Quadrant

Acronyms and Glossary

  • OEM - Original Aircraft Manufacture (real aircraft part).

Repair Backlighting on Throttle Quadrant

The rear of the First Officer side trim lightplate showing one of the two terminals that the wiring loom connects to

During a recent flight, I noticed that the bulbs that illuminate the backlighting for the trim and flaps lightplate (First Officer side) had failed, however, the backlighting on the Captain-side trim lightplate was illuminated.  My first thought was that the 5 volt bulbs that are integrated into the lightplate had burned out; after all, everything has an end life.

Backlighting - Wiring Loom

The wiring loom that supplies the power for the backlighting enters the throttle quadrant via the front firewall, and initially connects with the trim lightplate and parking brake release light on the Captain-side.  A Y-junction bifurcates the wire loom from the Captain-side to the First Officer side of the quadrant, before it snakes its way along the inside edge of the quadrant firewall to connect with the First Officer side trim lightplate, and then the flaps lightplate.  The wiring loom is attached securely to the inside edge of the throttle casing by screwed cable clamps.

The backlighting for all lightplates is powered by 5 volts and the backlighting on the throttle quadrant is turned on/off/dimmed by the pedestal lighting dimmer knob located on the center pedestal. 

Finding the Problem

Ascertaining whether the bulbs are burned out is uncomplicated, however, assessing the terminals on the rear of each lightplate, and the wiring loom the connects to the lightplates, does involve dismantling part of the throttle quadrant.

The upper section of the throttle quadrant must be dismantled (trim wheels, upper and side panels, and the saw tooth flaps arc).  This enables the inside of throttle quadrant to be inspected more easily with the aid of a torch (lamp/flashlight).  When removing the trim wheels, be especially vigilant not to accidently pull the spline shaft from its mount, as doing so will cause several cogs to fall out of position causing the trim mechanism to be inoperable.

After the lightplates have been removed, but still connected to the wiring loom, a multimeter is used to read the voltage of each respective terminal on the lightplate. If the mutlimeter indicates there is power to the terminals, then the bulbs should illuminate. 

What surprised me when this was done, was that the bulbs worked perfectly. Therefore, it was clear the problem was not bulb, but wire related.

Process of Elimination

The process of elimination is the easiest method to solve problems that may develop in complicated systems.  By reducing the components to their simplest form, a solution can readily be attained.

Alligator wire connects power from Captain-side lightplate to the First Officer lightplate.  Note the frayed outer layer of the white aircraft wire.  The gold colour is a thin layer of gold that acts as a fire retardant should the wiring overheat

If you suspect that the wiring is the problem, and don't have a multi meter, then a quick and fool safe method is to connect an alligator cable from the positive terminal of the Captain-side lightplate to the respective terminal on the First Officer lightplate.  Doing this removes that portion of the wiring harness from the circuit. 

In this scenario, the  bulbs illuminated on both trim lightplates.  As such, the problem was not bulb related, but was associated with the wiring loom.

It must be remembered that the wire used to connect the backlighting in the throttle quadrant is OEM wire.  As such, the age of the wire is the same age as the throttle quadrant.  

Inspecting the wire loom, I noticed that one of the wires that connected to the terminal of the lightplate was severed (cut in two).   I also noted that the original aircraft wires had begun to shed their protective insulation layer. 

Aircraft Wire and Insulation Layers

The high voltage and amperages that travel through aircraft wire can generate considerable heat.  This is why aircraft wire is made to very exacting standards and incorporates several layers of insulation that surround the stranded stainless steel wire.  The use of high-grade stainless steel also provides good strength and resistance to corrosion and oxidation at elevated temperatures.  

The green wire has been severed.  A possible scenario was that the wiring loom had been pulled slightly loose from the throttle chassis, and had become caught in the flaps mechanism.  When the flaps lever is moved, the mechanism can easily crimp (and eventually sever) any wire in its path.  If you observe the white wire you can see the insulation that is shedding

Interestingly, one of the insulating layers is comprised of gold (Au).  The gold acts as an effective fire retardant should the wires overheat.

The breakdown of the upper insulating layer is not a major cause for concern, as a 'shedding' wire still has enough insulation to not arc or short circuit.  However, the wire should be replaced if more than one layer is compromised, or the stainless threads of the wire are visible.

Possible Scenario

When inspecting the wiring loom, I noted that one of the screws that holds the cable clamp to the inside of the throttle casing was loose.  This resulted in part of the wire loom to 'hang' near the flaps arc mechanism.    It is possible that during the throttle’s operational use, the movement and vibration of the aircraft had caused the screw to become loose resulting in the wires hanging down further than normal.  It appears that the wire had been severed, because it became caught in the mechanism of the flaps lever.  

Unlike reproduction throttles, the parts used in an OEM throttle are heavy duty and very solid; they are designed to withstand considerable abuse.  The speedbrake lever, when activated can easily cut a pencil in two, and the repeated movement of the flaps lever, when moved quickly between the teeth of the flaps arc, can easily crimp or flatten a wire.

Rather than try to solder the wires together (soldering stainless wire is difficult) and possibly have the same issue re-occur, I routed the wires from both lightplates (trim and flaps) directly to the 5 volt bus bar located in the center pedestal. 

I could have removed the wire loom completely and replaced it with another loom, however, this would involve having to disassemble the complete upper structure of the throttle quadrant to access the wire loom attachment points on the inside of the throttle casing; something I was not keen to do.

Final Call

OEM parts, although used in a static and simulated environment can have drawbacks.  Apart from age, the repeated movement of mechanical parts and the vibration of the spinning trim wheels, can loosen screws and nuts that otherwise should be securely tightened. 

Acronyms

  • OEM – Original Equipment Manufacturer

  • Wire Loom – Several wires bundled together and attached to a fixed point by some type of clamp

Using OEM Panels in the MIP

OEM Captain-side DU panel.  Note the thick engraving and specialist DZUS fasteners

The introduction of the Boeing 737 Max has meant that many carriers are updating their fleets and retiring earlier production 737 NG airframes.  This has flow on benefits for flight simulator enthusiasts, because more and more OEM NG parts are becoming available due to NG airframes being stripped down and recycled.  

Although some items, such as high-end avionics are priced outside the realm of the average individual, many other parts have become reasonably priced and are often a similar price to the equivalent reproduction part.

This article primarily relates to the panels used in the Main Instrument Panel (MIP), and lower kick stand.  The term panel means the aluminum plate that is secured to the framework of the MIP, and lightplate refers to the engraved plate that is secured to the panel.

Do You Notice The Difference

This is a common question.  The resounding answer is yes – the difference between OEM and reproduction parts can be noticed, especially if you compare the identical parts side by side.  This said, some high-end companies manufacturer panels that are almost indiscernible from the OEM panel.  These panels are bespoke, expensive, and usually are only made to a custom order.  Therefore, it really depends on which manufacturer/company you are comparing the OEM panel against.

Close up detail of OEM lightplate and general purpose knobs

By far the biggest difference between an OEM and reproduction panel, other than appearance, is the tactile feel of a knob, the overall robustness of the panel, and the firmness felt when rotating a commercial-grade switch; the later feels very accurate in its movement. 

There is litle compromise with backlighting as an OEM panel has a consistent colour temperature and intensity without hot and cold spots.  

Using a real panel helps to provide immersion and, as your're using a real aircraft part there is no second-guessing whether the panel is an accurate copy; using an OEM panel is literally 'as real as it gets'.  Furthermore, it’s  environmentally friendly to use second hand parts.  New parts (reproduction or otherwise) are made from  finite resources. 

Limitation

Not every OEM part can work in a home simulator.  For example, the OEM potentiometer responsible for the dimming function in the lower kickstand DU panels cannot be used.  This is because Boeing use a rheostat instead of a potentiometer.  Without going into detail, a rheostat is designed to take into account 115 volts AC commonly used in aircraft.  If using these panels. you will need to change the rheostat to a high-end commercial potentiometer.  

Table 1 outlines 'some' of the main differences between the OEM panels and their reproduction equivalents.

Table 1:  Main differences between OEM and reproduction panels (MIP only).

The information presented in the above table, should not be taken in a way that reflects poorly on the manufacturer of reproduction panels.  There are a few high-end companies whose panels are indiscernible from the real item; it’s the purchaser’s knowledge and the manufacturer’s skill that will define whether a reproduction panel replicates the real item.  ‘Caveat Emptor’should always be at the forefront of any purchase decision.

Potential Problems Using OEM Panels in the MIP

Potential problems often surface when attempting to mate OEM parts to the framework of the MIP.  This is because reproduction MIPs rarely echo the identical dimensions of their OEM counterpart. 

OEM Stand-by instrument panel. Although difficult to see from a picture, the overall robustness of this panel surpasses all but the very best reproductions

It's not possible to document every potential problem, as all reproduction MIPs are slightly different to each other.  However, some issues encountered may be the misalignment of screw holes between the MIP framework and the OEM panel, the inability to use the panel's DZUS fasteners, the panel being too large or too small for the MIP in question, or the open framework structure at the rear of the panel (which incorporates the wiring lume and Canon plugs) interfering with the infrastructure of the reproduction MIP, or the mounting of the computer screens.

In general, OEM panels cannot be mounted to a reproduction MIP without major work being done to the framework of the MIP.   The solution is to use a MIP that has been designed 1:1 with the OEM MIP, or fabricate a MIP in-house to the correct dimensions.

Specifics to the FDS MIP

The MIP used in the simulator is manufactured by Flight Deck Solutions (FDS), and although the MIP is made to a very high quality, the dimensions of the MIP are not 1:1. 

The most problematic issue is that the MIP length is slightly too narrow to enable the OEM panels to be fit correctly to the front of the framework.  For example, the OEM chronograph panel is 1 cm wider than the FDS chronograph panel.  Furthermore, most of the OEM panels (such as the standby instrument, chronograph and landing gear panel) measure 130 mm in height as opposed to the FDS panels that measure 125 mm in height.  This causes problems when trying to line up the bottom of each panel with the bottom of the display bezels. 

The standby instrument panel does fit, however, there is a few centimeters of space between the panel and the adjacent display bezel frame.  In the real aircraft, the display bezel and the edge of the standby instrument panel almost abut one another.  The autobrake panel does fit as do the lower kickstand panels.

FDS use screws to attach their panels to the upper MIP framework, however, OEM panels use DZUS fasteners.  The screw holes on the FDS MIP do not align with the position of the DZUS fasteners in the OEM panel.  The lower MIP panel (kickstand) in the real aircraft also incorporates a DZUS rail to which the panels are attached.  The FDS kickstand does not use a DZUS rail, and screws or reproduction DZUS fasteners are needed to secure the OEM kickstand panels.

The above said, FDS does not state that their MIP is I:1, and when asked will will inform you that OEM panels will not fit their products without considerable fabrication.

DZUS fastener that secures DU panel to the MIP framework

Specialist DZUS Fasteners

The OEM panels used in the upper MIP incorporate into the panel a specialist DZUS fastener.  This fastener is used to tightly secure the panel to the framework of the MIP; screws are not used.  Screws are only used to secure the lightplate to the panel. 

The DZUS fastener is shaped differently to the fasteners used to secure the panels located in the lower kickstand, overhead and center pedestal, and these parts are not interchangeable. 

Reproductions rarely replicate these DZUS fasteners.  However, like many things it's often the small things that make a difference (at least aesthetically).

Rear of OEM Captain-side DU panel.   Note heavy duty rotary switches (Cole & Jaycor brand), neat and sturdy wiring lume, and easy connect Canon plug.  The use of the correct bracket in the panel enables the AFDS unit to fit snugly to the panel.  Note the depth of the external frame which can cause placement issues

Advantages Using OEM Wiring Lume and Canon Plugs

A major plus using any OEM panel is that the part usually includes an expertly-made wiring lume that terminates at Canon plug.    If possible, the original wiring lume should be kept intact and additional wiring should be done from the Canon plug.  It’s very difficult to duplicate the same level of workmanship that Boeing has done in relation to the wiring.  Furthermore, the wire that has been used is high-end aviation grade wire.

OEM landing gear panel. Like any OEM part, the neatness in relation to the wiring is immaculate.  A Canon plug enables the panel to be connected to a lume which then connects with whatever interface card is in use

The Canon plug deserves further mention, as the use of a Canon plug (or any connector for that matter) enables you to easily remove the panel for service work should this be required.  If at all possible, the original Canon plug (and wiring) should be used because it’s neat and tidy and ensures a good connection.  However, if the correct Canon plug cannot be procured then a reproduction plug should be fabricated.  There is nothing worse than having to disconnect wires from an interface card to remove a part.

Configuring an OEM Panel

Configuring an OEM panel to use in flight simulator depends on which panel you are referring to. 

Panels with knobs, toggles and switches are relatively straightforward to interface with a respective interface card (Phidget card, PoKeys card, FDS SYS card or similar).  Determining the pinouts on the Canon plug that control backlighting requires the use of a multimeter, and then connection to a 5 volt power supply.  If the panel includes annunciators (korrys), then these will need to be connected to a 28 volt power supply (using the correct pinouts).

Technology is rarely static, and there are other ways to interface and configure OEM panels.  The ARINC 429 protocol is becomminginceasingly common to use along with specialist interface cards, and these will be discussed in separate articles.

Rear of DU panel showing korry connections and AFDS bracket

The Future

The FDSMIP can, with some work, be modified to mount the OEM panels.  However, an easier option is to find another MIP that has been designed to mount the panels, or fabricate a MIP in-house to OEM dimensions.

Final Call

Aesthetically, nothing beats the use of an OEM panel, and the panels used in the upper MIP and lower kickstand offer little comparison to their reproduction equivalents, with possible exception to bespoke reproductions. By far the biggest challenge is determining the pin-outs for the Canon plug, but once known, configuration using a Phidget or other traditional card is relatively straightforward. 

As straightforward as it may seem, potential problems surface when attempting to mate OEM panels to an existing reproduction MIP.  To resolve these issues, often a replacement MIP is needed that has been made to the identical dimensions of the OEM counterpart.

Additional Information

The following articles may provide further information in relation to using OEM parts.

Acronyms

  • ARINC 429 - Aircraft communication protocol

  • DU - Display Unit

  • Lume - A harness that holds several wires in a neat way

  • OEM - Original Equipment Manufacturer

  • MIP - Main Instrument Panel

Flight Management System (FMS) Software and its Relationship with LNAV and VNAV

OEM 737 CDU page displaying the U version of software used by the Flight Management Computer.  The page also displays the current NavData version installed in addition to other information

The procedure to takeoff in a Boeing 737 is a relatively straightforward process, however, the use of automation, in particular pitch and roll modes (Lateral and Vertical Navigation), when to engage it, and what to expect once it has been selected, can befuddle new flyers.  

In this article I will explain some of the differences between versions of software used in the Flight Management System (FMS) and how its relates to Lateral and vertical Navigation (LNAV  & VNAV). 

It’s assumed the reader has a relatively good understanding of the use of LNAV and VNAV, how to engage this functionality, and how they can be used together or independently of each other.

FMS Software Versions

There are a several versions of software used in the FMC; which version is installed is dependent upon the airline, and it’s not unusual for airframes to have different versions of software.

The nomenclature for the FMC software is a letter U followed by the version number.  The version of software dictates, amongst other things, the level of automation available.  For the most part, 737 Next Generation airframes will be installed with version U10.6, U10.7 or later.

Boeing released U1 in 1984 and the latest version, used in the 737 Max is U13.

Later versions of FMC software enable greater functionality and a higher level of automation – especially in relation to LNAV and VNAV.

Differences in Simulation Software

The FMS software used by the main avionics suites (Sim Avionics, Project Magenta, PMDG and ProSim-AR) should be identical in functionality if they simulate the same FMS U number.  

As at 2018, ProSim-AR uses U10.8A and Sim Avionics use a hybrid of U10.8, which is primarily U10.8 with some other features taken from U11 and U12.  Precision Manuals Development Group (PMDG) uses U10.8A.  

Therefore, as ProSim-AR and PMDG both use U10.8A, it’s fair to say that everything functional in PMDG should also be operational in ProSim737.  Unfortunately, as of writing, PMDG is the only software that replicates U10.8A with 97+-% success rate.

To check which version is being used by the FMC, press INIT REF/INDEX/IDENT in the CDU.  

Writing about the differences between FMC U version can become confusing.   Therefore, to minimise misunderstanding and increase readability, I have set out the information for VNAV and LNAV using the FMC U number.   

Roll Mode (LNAV)

U10.6 and earlier

(i)    LNAV will not engage below 400 AGL;

(ii)    LNAV cannot be armed prior to takeoff; and,

(iii)    LNAV should only be engaged  when climb is stabilised, but after passing through 400 feet AGL.

U10.7 and later

(i)    If LNAV is selected or armed prior to takeoff, LNAV guidance will become active at 50 feet AGL as long as the active leg in the FMC is within 3 NM and 5 degrees of the runway heading.  

(i)    If the departure procedure or route does not begin at the end of the runway, it’s recommended to use HDG SEL (when above 400 feet AGL) to intercept the desired track for LNAV capture;

(ii)    When an immediate turn after takeoff is necessary, the desired heading should be preset in the MCP prior to takeoff;  and,

(iii)    If the departure procedure is not part of the active flight plan, HDG SEL or VOR LOC should be used until the aircraft is within range of the flight plan track (see (i) above).

Important Point:

•    LNAV (U10.7 and later) can only be armed if the FMC has an active flight plan.

Pitch Mode (VNAV)

U10.7 and earlier

(i)    At Acceleration Height (AH), lower the aircraft’s nose to increase airspeed to flaps UP manoeuvre speed;

(ii)    At Thrust Reduction Altitude (800 - 1500 feet), select or verify that the climb thrust has been set (usually V2+15 or V2+20);

(iii)    Retract flaps as per the Flaps Retraction Schedule (FRS); and,

(iv)    Select VNAV or climb speed in the MCP speed window only after flaps and slats have been retracted.

Important Points:

  • VNAV cannot be armed prior to takeoff.

  • Remember that prior to selecting VNAV, flaps should be retracted, because VNAV does not provide overspeed protection for the leading edge devices when using U10.7 or earlier.

U10.8 and later 

(i)    VNAV can be engaged at anytime because VNAV in U10.8 provides overspeed protection for the leading edge devices;

(ii)    If VNAV is armed prior to takeoff, the Auto Flight Direction System (AFDS) remains in VNAV when the autopilot is engaged.  However, if another pitch mode is selected, the AFDS will remain in that mode;

(iii)    When VNAV is armed prior to takeoff, it will engage automatically at 400 feet.  With VNAV engaged, acceleration and climb out speed is computed by the FMC software and controlled by the AFDS; and,

(iv)    The Flaps should be retracted as per the flaps retraction schedule;

(v)    If VNAV is not armed prior to takeoff, at Acceleration Height set the command speed to the flaps UP manoeuvre speed; and,

(vi)    If VNAV is not armed prior to takeoff, at Acceleration Height set the command speed to the flaps UP manoeuvre speed.

Important Points:

  • VNAV can be armed prior to takeoff or at anytime.

  • At thrust reduction altitude, verify that climb thrust is set at the point selected on the takeoff reference page in the CDU.  If the thrust reference does not change automatically, climb thrust should be manually selected.

  • Although the VNAV profile and acceleration schedule is compatible with most planned departures, it’s prudent to cross check the EICAS display to ensure the display changes from takeoff (TO) to climb or reduced climb (R-CLB).  

Auto Flight Direction System (AFDS) – Operation During Takeoff and Climb

U10.7 and earlier

If the autopilot is engaged prior to the selection of VNAV:

(i)    The AFDS will revert to LVL CHG;

(ii)    The pitch mode displayed on the Flight Mode Annunciator (FMA) will change from TOGA to MCP SPD; and,

(iii)    If a pitch mode other than TOGA is selected after the autopilot is engaged, the AFDS will remain in that mode.

U10.8 and later

(i)    If VAV is armed for takeoff, the AFDS remains in VNAV when the autopilot is engaged; and,   

(ii)    If a pitch mode other than VNAV is selected, the AFDS will remain in that mode.

Preparing for Failure

LNAV and VNAV have their shortcomings, both in the real and simulated environments.

To help counteract any failure, it’s good airmanship to set the heading mode (HDG) on the MCP to indicate the bearing that the aircraft will be flying.  Doing this ensures that, should LNAV fail, the HDG button can be quickly engaged with minimal time delay; thereby, minimising any deviation from the aircraft’s course.

Final Call

I realise that some readers, who only wish to learn the most recent software, will not be interested in much of the content of this article.  Notwithstanding this, I am sure many will have discovered something they may have been forgotten or overlooked.

The content of this short article came out of a discussion on a pilot’s forum.  If there is doubt, always consult the Flight Crew Training Manual (FCTM) which provides information specific to the software version used at that particular airline.

Glossary

  • CDU – Computer Display Unit.

  • EFIS – Electronic Flight Instrument System.

  • FMA – Flight Mode Annunciator.

  • FMC – Flight Management Computer.

  • FMS - Flight Management System.

  • LVL CHG – Level Change.

  • LNAV – Lateral Navigation.

  • MCP – Mode Control Panel.

  • ND – Navigation Display.

  • PFD – Primary Flight Display


  • VNAV – Vertical Navigation.

Differences in Colour, Manufacturer, and Layout in the Center Pedestal

There are several panels that make up the center pedestal, main instrument panel, and overhead in the Boeing 737 aircraft. Most of the panels are required by international law, and a carrier cannot fly if certain panels do not function correctly.

Although the aviation regulations require aircraft to have certain panels, there are panels that are airline specific. These panels are chosen when the aircraft is ordered from Boeing, or they may be installed at a later on. Similar to automobiles, there are a number of manufacturers of aviation panels and each panel, although having identical functionality may differ slightly.

All high-end simulators replicate the panels required by the authorities, and enthusiasts often fixate on a number of supposed issues. Namely:

(i)         The colour of the panel and lightplate;

(ii)        The position of the panel in the center pedestal;

(iii)       The backlighting of the lightplate (bulbs verses LEDs);

(iv)       The manufacturer of the panel, and;

(v)        The aesthetic condition of the lightplate.

Although seemingly important to a cockpit builder, to the casual observer, or indeed to many pilots, these attributes are of little consequence.  Nevertheless, it's understandable to a newcomer that all panels in the 737 Next Generation are identical between all aircraft.

Whilst it's true that all airlines must meet aviation standards for the type of operation they fly, the panel manufacturer and where in the pedestal the panel is located is at the discretion of the airline.  Furthermore, it's not uncommon to observe older style panels mixed with modern panels and to see lightplates that are illuminated by bulbs and LEDs side by side.

Note that some of this information probably pertains more to older Next Generation 737s than to the latest Next Generation released from Boeing.  I use the word 'panel' to denote an avionics module.

Air Alaska 737-700 pedestal.  Note higher than standard position of ACP panels and relocated position of the door lock panel.  Also high mounted position of rudder trim panel

Colour of Lightplates

The official colour shade used by Boeing is Federal Standard 5956 36440 (light gull grey).  However, OEM part manufacturers may use slightly different colour hues.  For example, IPECO use British Standard 381C-632 (dark admiralty grey) and Gables use RAL 7011.  This said, often an airline will 'touch up' a lightplate that is damaged or faded - this introduces a further colour variant. 

For example, a lightplate I acquired from a 737-500 airframe revealed three differing shades of grey beneath the final top coat of paint.  This is not to mention that, depending on the manufacturer of the lightplate, the final coat of paint may be matt, semi-matt or gloss.

From the perspective of an engineer, the colour (and to a certain extent aesthetic condition) is unimportant when replacing a defective part with another.  Time spent in the hanger equates to a loss in revenue by the airline.  Therefore turn-around times are as brief as possible and keeping an aircraft on the ground while procuring the correct shade of Boeing grey does not enter the equation.

Position of Panels in the Center Pedestal

Boeing recommends a more or less standard position for the essential panels in the center pedestal (NAV, COM, ADF, ASP, rudder trim, door lock and panel flood), however, the location of the panels is often altered by the receiving airline, and is to a certain extent is determined by what other panels are installed to the pedestal.  Areas (holes) in the pedestal not used by a panel are covered over with a grey-coloured metal blank.

LEFT:  This photograph of the center pedestal of a Boeing 737-500 was taken in 2016.  The aircraft is a freighter converted from a passenger aircraft.  Apart from the older style ACP panels, note the disparate displays between the NAV and COM radios.  Also note the position of the ADF radios and some of the other panels; they do not conform to what is usually thought of as a standard set-out.  Finally, note the scratches on the pedestal and on some of the panels and lightplates - they hardly look new.

Panels are manufactured by several companies, and often there appearance will differ slightly between manufacturer, although the panel's functionality will be identical.  The airline more often than not chooses which panel is used, and often the decision is biased by the cost of the panel.  Therefore, it's not uncommon to observe several airframes of a similar age with differing panels positioned in different areas of the center pedestal.

Panel Condition

Enthusiasts pride themselves in having a simulator that looks brand new.  However, in the real world a Level D simulator or flight deck rarely looks new after entering service.  Panels can be soiled and paint is chipped and scratched, and depending on age, some lightplates are faded to due to the high UV environment that is present in a flight deck.

So where am I going with this?  Enthusiasts strive to match their panels with those observed in a real airliner, however, more often than not this information comes from photographs distributed by Boeing Corporation, which nearly always depict panels in a standard position, especially in relation to the center pedestal. 

The variables noted by enthusiasts should not cause consternation, as real aircraft show similar variation.  Remember that in the real aircraft, colour, manufacturer, and to a certain extent aesthetic condition is not important - functionality is.

Conversion of OEM CDU - Part Two

OEM CDU operational with ProSim737

In this second article, I will explain how the OEM Control Device Unit (CDU) was converted to enable a SimStack Foundation Board to be installed inside the unit and connected to ProSim737. 

SimStacks are manufactured by Simulator Solutions, which is a Sydney based company in Australia and their foundation boards can be used with ProSim737 and ProSim320 avionics suites. 

This is but one method to convert an OEM item to be used with flight simulator.

This article will mainly address the mechanical conversion of the CDU.  A future article, after flight testing,  will provide a review of SimStacks interface cards.

Conversion

Many of the OEM parts used in the simulator have been converted using Phidget cards, and to a lesser extent Leo Bodnar and PoKeys interface cards.  Phidgets provide a stable platform, despite the disadvantage that they, at time of writing, can only connect via USB to the server computer, and don’t enable every OEM function to be used in ProSim-AR.  The primary advantage of using Phidgets is that they have been used in a wide variety of applications, are inherently stable, and their configuration is well documented.

I decided that, rather than use Phidgets, a different system would be trailed to interface the CDU with ProSim737. 

he SimStack Foundation Board mounted on an angular bracket inside the CDU.  Fortunately there is ample room to mount the board inside the CDU

SimStacks by Simulator Solutions

The conversion of the CDU was done in collaboration with Sydney-based company Simulator Solutions Pty Ltd.  Simulator Solutions use their propriety interface boards called SimStacks to convert OEM parts for use in commercial-grade simulators.

SimStacks is a modular, stackable, and scalable hardware interface that is designed to integrate OEM parts into your simulator with little or no modification.    One of the many advantages in using a SimStack board is that the interface can connect with either the server or client computer via Ethernet (as opposed to Phidgets). 

To date, Simulator Solution’s experience has been predominately with the conversion of B747 parts and Rodney and John (owners) were excited to have the opportunity to evaluate their software on the 737 platform using ProSim737. 

Converting the CDU - Choose Your Poison

There are two main camps when discussing how to convert an OEM part.  The first is to use as much of the original wiring and parts as possible.  The second is to completely ‘gut’ the part and convert it cleanly using an interface that connects seamlessly with the avionics software in use (ProSim-AR).  A third option, although expensive and in many respects ‘experimental’, is to use ARINC 429. 

ARINC 429 is a protocol used in real aircraft to enable panels etc to be connected with the aircraft’s systems, and although it can be used in a simulated environment, it’s not without its shortfalls, in particular, the use of AC power (in contrast to DC power).

To use SimStacks the internal components of the CDU had to be removed, with the  exception of the internal shelf divider and keypad.  In hindsight, the pin-outs of the Canon plugs could have been used, but in doing so a female Canon plug would have been required, and for the use of a couple of pins, the price of a Canon female plug was expensive.

Keypad and Screen

The keypad and screen are the two most important parts of the CDU. 

The keypad forms part of the lightplate.  The backlighting for the keypad is powered by 21 5 Volt incandescent bulbs, strategically located to ensure even backlighting of the keys.

table 1: provides an overview of bulb location, part number and quantity

Like anything, bulbs have a limited left and, although OEM bulbs are renown for their longevity, there is always a chance that some bulbs are broken.  In this case, there were 3 bulbs that needed replacement.

Disassembling and removing the keypad from the main body of the CDU is straightforward; several small Philips head screws hold the keypad in place.  Once the keypad has been removed, any ‘blown’ bulbs can be replaced. 

The most important area is the keypad is what is called the terminus (bus).  Several wires from the keypad travel to the bus and then to the various (now removed) parts in the CDU.  The Simstack Foundation Board is wired to the bus, therefore, care must be taken to not damage these wires between the bus and the keypad. 

737 CL CDU showing older green coloured text displayed on CRT screen

I found that the wires were quite short and needed to be lengthened; this can be done by splicing longer wire to the existing wire.  Although it's possible to replace the wire to the keypad, this would entail re soldering the wires to the various keypad points - a process that requires very exact soldering.

CRT screen showing thick curved glass

CRT and LCD Screen

The Classic CDU from airframes up to the Boeing 737-500 is fitted with a solid glass cathode ray tube (CRT) screen. 

The CRT screen is approximately 2 cm thick, curved in design, and fits snugly within the display frame of the CDU.  Although it’s possible to make this screen operational, the display will be mono-colour (green) and the screen resolution poor.  Therefore, the CRT was replaced with a custom-sized high resolution colour LCD screen.

To replace the CRT screen is not without its challenges.  The first being that the LCD screen is not 2 cm in thickness and will not fit snugly within the curved display recess of the CDU frame.  To rectify this shortfall, a piece of clear glass must be ground to correctly fit within the frame.  This piece of glass replaces the 2 cm thick, curved CRT glass.

Photo showing how the thin LCD screen was secured with tape the glass screen.  Although the process appears rudimentary, it's functional

The thin LCD screen is installed directly behind the clear glass using high density tape.  Commercial grade double-sided sticky tape is the easiest method, but it is rudimentary.  The reason that tape is used, is that should the screen fail, it’s easy to remove the tape, install a replacement screen, and then tape the screen in place.

During the design phase, it was thought that the thick piece of glass would cause a refraction problem.  However, although the theory suggests refraction will occur, the practical application has been such that any refraction is not readily noticeable.

Installing the SimStacks Foundation Board and Screen Controller Card

To enable the CDU to operate, four items need to be mounted inside the CDU.

(i)   The generic Interface card that controls the LCD screen;

(ii)   The LCD screen controller (buttons that control brightness, contrast, etc);

(iii)  The SimStack Foundation Board; and,

(iv)  The wiring to connect the keyboard to the Foundation Board.

Fortunately, there is ample room in the cavernous interior of the CDU to fit these items. 

The SimStack Foundation Board is mounted on an angular metal bracket that is attached directly to the bottom of the CDU, while the LCD interface card has been installed on the upper shelf along with the screen controller.  A ribbon cable connects the LCD screen to the interface card while a standard VGA cable connects the LCD screen to the client computer and Ethernet switch. 

The SimStack Foundation Board is Ethernet ready and requires a standard Ethernet cable (CAT 6) to connect from the card to an Ethernet switch (located behind the MIP).  In addition to the Ethernet  and VGA cable, six power wires leave the CDU via the rear of the casing; four from the SimStack Foundation Board (5 and 12 volts +-) and two from the keypad (5 volts +-) to control the backlighting.

The specialist switch and wiring (Ethernet, power and VGA cables) extruding from the rear of the CDU

Specialist Switch and Power Supply

A standard two-way toggle switch is mounted to the rear of the CDU casing. 

This switch is used to control whether the LCD screen, used in the CDU, is always on, or is only turned on when ProSim-AR is activated.

To operate the CDU requires a 5 and 12 volt power supply.  The backlighting of the keypad is powered by 5 volts while the SimStack Foundation Board and CDU operation require 12 volts.

Backlight Dimming (keypad)

To enable the CDU keypad to be dimmed, the 5 volt wires are connected to a dedicated 5 volt Busbar located in the center pedestal.  This Busbar is used to connect the backlighting from all OEM panels.  The Busbar is then connected to the panel knob on the center pedestal.  The ability to turn the backlighting on and off is controlled by opening or closing a 12 volt relay (attached in line between the panel knob and Busbar).  Dimming is controlled by a dimmer circuit (see earlier article).

Installing the OEM CDU to Flight Deck Solutions MIP

It can be challenging attempting to install OEM panels, gauges and other items to a reproduction Main Instrument Panel (MIP).  Unfortunately, no matter what the manufacturer states, many MIPS do not comply with real world measurements.  

Before and after photograph of the FDS CDU bay showing the small flange from the shelf that needed to be trimmed to enable the CDU to slide into the bay recess.  A small notch was made at the corner to facilitate the safe routing of the wires used to enable the Lights Test

The MIP skeleton is manufactured by Flight Deck Solutions (FDS) and the CDU bay, although fitted with OEM DZUS rails, is designed to fit FDS’s propriety CDU unit (MX Pro) and not an OEM unit. 

The casing for the OEM CDU is much longer than the FDS CDU and measures 20 cm in length.

The FDS MIP design is such that the aluminum shelf (used by FDS to mount various interface cards) protrudes slightly into the rear of the CDU bay.  This protrusion stops the OEM casing from sliding neatly into the bay to its fullest extent.  To enable the CDU to slide into the CDU bay, the shelf must be ‘trimmed’.

To trim the metal away from the shelf, a small metal saw was used, and although an easy task, care must be taken not to ‘saw away’ too much metal.  Once the piece of offending aluminum is removed, the CDU slides perfectly into the bay, to be secured by DZUS fasteners to the DZUS rail.

Functionality and Operation

The CDU is not intelligent; it’s basically a glorified keyboard that must be interfaced with ProSim-AR to enable the CDU to function correctly.  The fonts and colour of the fonts is generated by the avionics suite (in this case ProSim-AR, but arguably it could also be Sim Avionics or Project Magenta). 

To enable communication between the avionics suite and the SimStack Foundation Board, proprietary software must be installed.  This software has been developed by Simulator Solutions.

SimStack Software (simswitch)

Screen grab showing SimSwitch software User Interface.  SimSwitch is standalone once the initial configuration has been completed.  The software can be configured to open in minimised mode via a batch file

To enable communication between the Foundation Board and ProSim737, propriety software, called SimSwitch must be installed to the computer that has the CDU connected. 

SimSwitch is a JAR executable file, that when configured with the correct static IP address and port numbers, provides communication between ProSim-AR (on the server computer) and the network (clients).  The switch must be opened for communication to occur between the Foundation Board, SimSwitch and ProSim737.  The jar file can easily be included into a batch file (with timer command) for automatic loading when flight simulator is used.

When opened, SimSwitch displays the User Interface.  The User Interface displays all OEM panels that have been connected using a SimStacks, can be used to monitor connected panels, and can display debugging information (if required).

Independent Operation

The Captain and First Officer CDUs are not cloned (although this is easy to do), but operate as separate units.  This is identical to the operation in the real aircraft, whereby the Captain and First Officer are responsible for specific tasks when inputting the information into the CDU.

First Officer CDU

The First Officer CDU will be converted using a similar technique, with the exception that this unit will be converted more ‘cleanly’.  Rather than use an angled plate on which to attach the SimStacks Foundation Board, a solid aluminum plate will be used.  The LCD screen controller card will also be attached to the rear of the LCD screen.  Finally, to enable fast and easy removal of the CDU, the connection of the Ethernet cable will be outside of the unit.

Additional Information

SoarByWire (another enthusiast) has written an excellent article dealing with interfacing SimStacks.

Below is a short video demonstrating the operation of the OEM CDU using ProSim737.

Main points to note in the video are:

  • Heavy duty tactile keys.

  • The definite click that is heard when depressing a key.

  • The solid keypad (the keys do not wobble about in their sockets).

  • Although subjective, the appearance of the OEM CDU looks more aesthetically pleasing that a reproduction unit.

 
 

Final Call

The conversion has been successful and, when connected with ProSim737 via SimSwitch, all the functions available in the CDU work correctly.

Glossary

  • ARINC 429 –  A standard used to  address data communications between avionics components.  The most widely used  standard is an avionics data bus.  ARINC 429 enables a single transmitter to communicate data to up to 20 receivers over a single bus.

  • Standalone – Two meanings.  Operation does not require an interface card to be mounted outside of the panel/part; and, In relation to software, the executable file (.exe) does not need to be installed to C Drive, but can be executed from any folder or the desktop.

  • Updated for clarity and information 12 June 2020.

Alternate Use for OEM Rudder Pedal Circuit Breakers

OEM circuit breaker switch.  The two connectors on the rear of the switch are very easy to connect to an interface card for push/pull functionality

The picture at left is of an OEM circuit breaker that has been removed from an OEM rudder crank unit.  The front plate of the control mechanism has several circuit breakers on the Captain and First Officer-side of the flight deck.

Although connection of the circuit breakers, to the original functionality that was assigned to the switch in the aircraft, is not necessary (unless wanted), there is no reason why the circuit breakers cannot be used for additional functionality outside of the simulator environment.   Many enthusiasts have specially made panels that reside in the center pedestal to address such a need. 

The circuit breakers are basically an on/off push/pull switch.  Each switch can be easily wired to a standard interface card, such as a Pokeys or Leo Bodnar card, and then configured in ProSim-AR to a particular function.  If using FSUIPC, the functionality of the switch can be assigned to any on/off function.

For example, using FSUPIC (buttons) it is possible to assign each circuit breaker to a simulator function such as: pause, sim acceleration, jetway extension, etc.  The list is almost endless.

In my simulator, I have the Captain-side circuit breaker switches configured to simulator pause and simulator time acceleration.  These commands are readily accessible within the FSUIPC framework.

The circuit breaker switches are aesthetics, therefore, configuring the switches to regularly used commands is a way to minimize keyboard usage, and de-clutter the flight deck.

This post is not exactly a thrilling entry. 

I am working on three articles at the moment and a detailed review of the SimWorld MCP and EFIS.  I also am slowly updating previous articles to take into account changes to technology and ideas.

I hope to have these ready for publishing in the not to distant future.   Best,   F2A

OEM Rudder Crank Unit

OEM rudder adjusting crank unit installed to Captain-side kick-stand.  The upper portion of the stick shaker can be seen in the foreground

The two OEM rudder adjusting crank units have been sitting in storage for considerable time, and I thought it was time to add them to the simulator and replace the very poorly made and ‘cheesy’ reproductions.

The unit is not a small item that can easily be attached to the lower kick stand of the Main Instrument Panel (MIP).  Each crank handle attaches to a 8-inch-long box, that houses the various circuitry, cabling and a dozen or so aircraft circuit breakers. 

Connection to the aircraft’s system is via two Canon plugs at the rear of the unit, while movement of the pedals forward or aft is facilitated by a long metal cable that connects to the rear of the handle.

The unit is not light-weight and weighs in at just over 1 kilogram.

The rudder crank handles do nothing other than add to the aesthetics of the simulator.  However, if wanted the various circuit breakers can be connected to an interface card (I will not be doing this).

rudder adjusting crank unit (prior to cleaning).  The long metal cable that connects to the rear of the handle (enabling the forward and aft adjustment of the pedals) has been removed.  The white crank handle hangs loose and needs to be attached to the box using plastic fasteners (empty holes).  The black circular pull on/off circuit breakers can be seen below the white handle

Installation to MIP

There are several methods that can be used to install the mechanism to the Main Instrument Panel (MIP).

If you are using an OEM MIP, then connection of the mechanism to the kick-stand is a matter of using the existing bolts and placement holes.  Fitment to a reproduction MIP is accomplished differently and depends upon how the MIP has been fabricated. 

I fabricated an aluminium cradle (saddle) that is attached by two nuts and bolts to the lower portion of the kick-stand (under the kick-stand out of sight).  The rudder adjusting crank unit slides into the cradle and a small screw holds the unit in the correct place.  A similar assembly could easily be made from wood or ABS plastic and painted Boeing grey.

The method of attachment differs to the way the unit is attached in the real aircraft  (classic or Next Generation).  I have abutted the upper section of the unit against the lower kick-stand.  In the real aircraft the mechanism is attached by a metal mounting bracket and screws.  As stated above, the type of MIP you are using and how it's fabricated indicates the best way to attach the unit (unless you want to bastardise the MIP).

737 Next Generation rudder adjusting crank (courtesy @ Karl)

Classic (500 series)

The rudder adjusting crank I have installed is from a classic 500 series airframe.  The difference between the classic and the Next Generation is minimal, however the method that the mechanism is attached to the lower kick-stand differs considerably. 

The classic is as shown in the above two images while the Next Generation, shown at left connects directly to the kick-stand via a a series of brackets that form part of the lower kick-stand structure. 

For those who are interested in a reproduction unit, AeroSim Solutions in Australia has a reasonable facsimile.

Read about an alternate use of the circuit breakers.

  • Updated 25 June 2020.

Conversion of OEM CDU - Part One

Completely gutted.  All unnecessary and unusable electronic components have been removed

One of the more advanced projects is the conversion of two OEM Control Display Units manufactured by Smiths.  The two CDUs came from a Boeing 500 series airframe that was retired from service in 2008 due to United Airlines decision to adopt the Airbus A-320.  A chronometer located on the rear of each unit, shows the hours of use - one unit has 5130 hours while the other has 1630 hours.

The Control Display Unit (CDU) is the interface that the flight crew use to access and manipulate the data from the Flight Management Computer (FMC); it's basically a screen and keyboard.  The FMC in turn is but one part of a complex system called the Flight Management System (FMS).  The FMS is capable of four dimensional area navigation.  It is the FMS that contains the navigational database.  Often the words CDU and FMC are used interchangeably.

In this article I will discuss some of differences between OEM and reproduction CDUs. In addition to explaining some of the advantages that using an OEM unit brings.  A second article will deal with the actual conversion of the units to operate with ProSim737.

Port side of CDU with casing removed to show the electronic boards that are secured by lever clips.  Like anything OEM, the unit is constructed from solid component

Construction and Workmanship

The construction and workmanship that has gone into producing anything OEM is quite astounding. 

The CDU is built like a battleship and no amount of use or abuse can damage the unit.  The unit is quite large and heavy.  I was surprised at the eight, a good 6 kilograms.  Most of the weight is made up by the thick glass display screen  CRT, and other components that reside behind the glass within the sturdy aluminium case. 

A myriad number of small screws hold together the 1 mm thick aluminium casing that protects the internal components.  In addition to screws, there are two special DZUS fasteners, that when unlatched, enable the side of the unit’s casing to be removed for maintenance. 

When the casing of the CDU is removed, the inside is jammed full of components, from the large CRT screen to gold-plated electronic boards that are clipped into one of three internal shelves.

One aspect in using anything OEM is the ease at which the item can be inserted into the flight deck.  DZUS attachments enable the unit, once it has been slid into the CDU bay, to be securely fastened.  I use a MIP manufactured by Flight Deck Solutions and the CDU slides seamlessly into the CDU bay.

Detail of the keyboard and DIM knob.  Interestingly the DIM knob dims the actual CRT screen and not the backlighting

Tactile Differences

Aside from external build quality, one of the main differences you immediately notice between an OEM and reproduction CDU, is the tactile feeling when depressing the keys on the keyboard.  The keys do not wobble in their sockets like reproduction keys, but are firm to press and emit a strong audible click. 

Furthermore, the backlighting is evenly spread across the rear of the keyboard panel with each key evenly illuminated.

Aesthetic Differences – 500 Series and Next Generation

As the CDU dates from 2008, the external appearance isn’t identical to the CDU used in the Next Generation airframe, however, it is very close.

Main Differences:

  • The dim knob is a slightly different shape.

  • The display screen is rounded at the corners od the screen (the NG is more straight-edged).

  • The absence of the horizontal white lines located on the inside edge of the display frame bezel.

  • The display screen is different (cathode ray tube (CRT) in contrast to liquid crystal display (LCD).

  • The illumination is powered by bulbs.

In terms of functionality, as this is controlled by software (ProSim737) the functionality is identical.  This also holds true for the font type and colour.

To an absolute purist, these differences may be important, and if so, you will have to contend with a reproduction CDU, or pay an exorbitant amount for a decommissioned NG unit. 

OEM CDU installed to MIP functioning with ProSim737

Conversion for use with ProSim737

There are many ways to convert a real aircraft part for use in Flight Simulator.  By far the most professional and seamless is the integration of the real part using the ARINC429 protocol language (as used in the real aircraft).  However, using ARINC429 is not a simple process for all applications.  Not too mention that you often must use high voltage AC power.

For the most part I’ve used Phidgets to convert real parts, however, in this conversion I wanted to try a different approach.  I’m going to liaise with an Australian company called Simulator Solutions.  This company specialises in converting high-end electronic components used in commercial flight simulators, and manufactures an interface board that should enable seamless conversion of the CDU.

Glossary

  • ARINC 429 –  A standard used to  address data communications between avionics components.  The most widely used  standard is an avionics data bus.  ARINC 429 enables a single transmitter to communicate data to up to 20 receivers over a single bus.

  • OEM - Original Equipment Manufacture (aka real aircraft part).

White Caps for Locking Toggle Switches on Overhead

Lower electrical panel showing reproduction latex-style cap (ELEC 2) and OEM Honeywell Switch Accessory 15PA90-6W (ELEC 1). For those with keen eyes - yes that is a voice recorder in the lower panel - more to follow in later posts.  Of interest are the two different white caps (read main text)

It has taken a very long time to collect the assortment of OEM needed parts to complete the forward and aft overhead panels.  Finally the build is now in progress and it’s hoped completion will be towards the end of 2016.

OEM Overhead Panel Switches (2 main types)

There are two main types of switches used on the forward and aft overhead panel.  The push/throw switches (Honeywell switches pictured above) and the normal toggle-type switches.  The Honeywell switches use a screw on white cap while the standard toggle switches use use a condom style white cap.

Honeywell Switch Accessory 15PA90-6W showing internal screw thread.  The thread screws onto the stem of the toggle switch

Anatomy of the OEM White Cap

The Honeywell switch caps are not a slip-on latex cover but a solidly-produced head with an internal aluminium thread.  The head is designed to be screwed directly to the shaft of the toggle switches.  Firmly attached to this head is the white latex cap. This is the cap that is used on the push/throw switches. 

Reproductions

Most of the reproduction white caps for the push / throw switches are either push-on style condoms, or a white-capped head attached to a slender hollow shaft.  The shaft then slides over the existing switch stem. 

The reproduction slip-on caps currently available on the market bear little resemblance to those made by Honeywell.

Important Point:

  • Bear in mind that the push / throw switches are used regularly and are usually forcefully manipulated; many reproductions do not stand up to continued abuse.

Choice - so many options

I had purchased several dozen OEM Honeywell toggle switches, however, for whatever reason the white caps on the toggles were either missing or damaged.  Honeywell OEM switches are not inexpensive, so I was going to use reproduction white push-on caps (aka white condoms), but the caps failed to  fit snugly to the OEM switches, and their appearance was slightly different to the OEM version - the ends of the caps looked rather bulbous.

My next choice was to use latex caps that are used in automotive industry.  Once again, the appearance was slightly different and the automotive caps sported a small nipple at the end of each cap where they had been connected to the plastic retaining spur; I found the appearance of the nipple disconcerting.

Short of viable options, I purchased the OEM white caps from Honeywell which is the company that supplies Boeing.  If you carefully look at the above picture of the lower electrical panel (click image to enlarge picture), you will observe the nearest toggle switch has been fitted with an automotive style cap; the nipple and joining line is clearly visible.  The second toggle switch is fitted with the Honeywell white cap.

Installing the White Toggle Cap

To mount the white cap to a Honeywell switch you must first gently heat the switch stem.  The heat will loosen the head of the toggle.  It then is an easy matter to screw off the head and replace it with the OEM head.  To heat the stem use either a hair dryer or paint dry gun (used to dry paint).

Measurements

Not everyone wants to utilise OEM parts.  As such I have provided the measurements of the switch head (courtesy of Honeywell) for those who wish to try their hand at making their own white caps.

If you are searching for the other style of white caps used on the standard toggle switches, the part number for the correct condom white cap is 69-44578-2.

Reproduction Condoms - suppliers

For those not wishing to use OEM, there are several companies that manufacture reproduction white toggle caps.  For example, PC Flights and GLB United Kingdom.

Glossary

  • Honeywell – Avionics conglomerate that is heavily involved in the defense and aviation industries.

  • OEM – Original Equipment Manufacture.